Meta đã thành lập Ủy ban Giám sát để hỗ trợ chúng tôi giải đáp một số câu hỏi hóc búa nhất xoay quanh quyền tự do biểu đạt trên mạng, đó là: cần gỡ bỏ nội dung nào, cần để lại nội dung nào và tại sao.
Mục đích của ủy ban
Ủy ban là một cơ quan bên ngoài mà mọi người có thể gửi đơn kháng nghị nếu không đồng tình với quyết định thực thi của Meta về nội dung trên Facebook, Instagram hoặc Threads. Chúng tôi cam kết thực thi các quyết định của ủy ban về nội dung. Đồng thời, những đề xuất mà ủy ban đưa ra sẽ góp phần định hình cách chúng tôi quản lý chính sách.
The Oversight Board overturned Meta's original decision to remove the first piece of content and one photo in the photo carousel of the second piece of content from Instagram.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle appealed by Facebook and Instagram users regarding two pieces of content involving the use of monkey emojis to refer to Black people.
The Oversight Board issued a summary decision on a case which deals with a Facebook post containing a video depicting an elderly person holding a sign that reads, in Spanish: “Trading wellness chocolate for insulin.”
The Oversight Board issued a summary decision on a case which deals with a Facebook post containing a link to a news article about a gunman firing at a church in Sri Lanka.
The Oversight Board overturned Meta’s original decision to remove an Instagram post featuring a poem about political protest in Argentina. Meta had already reinstated the content, and no further action will be taken on this case.
The Oversight Board issued a summary decision on a case which deals with a Facebook post criticizing Senegal's debt levels under former President Macky Sall that included the statement that Mr. Sall deserves 'the public guillotine.'
The Oversight Board issued a summary decision on a case which deals with a Facebook comment targeting Romani people, stating they “should not exist” and are “only [a] problem for the world.” The comment was made on a post discussing the history of migrations of the Romani people.
The Oversight Board issued a summary decision on a case which deals with a video posted to Facebook featuring a clip of a televised interview with Qais Hadi Sayed Hasan al-Khazali, a politician, cleric and militant leader of Asa’ib Ahl al-Haq, an Iraqi Shia paramilitary organization and political party.
The Oversight Board upheld Meta's decision to leave up the content with warning labels in the French case and overturned Meta's decision to remove the content in the Indian case.
The Oversight Board selected a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a video posted shortly after former Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte was arrested to face charges before the International Criminal Court (ICC) for alleged crimes against humanity.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle regarding two Instagram photo carousel posts shared during National Eating Disorder Awareness Weeks in separate years.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle regarding four posts in Somali published to a Facebook page that describes itself as belonging to freelance journalism.
Alleged Audio Call to Rig Elections in Iraqi Kurdistan
The Oversight Board issues a decision on a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding an audio clip posted by a prominent media outlet in Iraqi Kurdistan ahead of their parliamentary elections.
The Oversight Board selected a case appealed by an Instagram user regarding a carousel of text-only images in Spanish that form a poem about political protest in Argentina.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case bundle involving four posts which include images and videos posted to Instagram and Facebook depicting indigenous women with their breasts uncovered in non-sexual contexts.
Comment on Kenyan Politics Using a Designated Slur
The Oversight Board selected case regarding a comment on a post about former Deputy President of Kenya Rigathi Gachagua’s support for former Kenyan Prime Minister Raila Odinga’s candidacy in the election for the African Union’s Chairperson.
The Oversight Board issued decisions in a case bundle which deals with fifteen Facebook and Instagram posts featuring different types of breast cancer awareness content.
The Oversight Board issued a summary decision on a case which deals with a video posted to Facebook depicting 'Estado Mayor Central' (EMC) a conglomerate of dissident factions of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC).
The Oversight Board issued a decision on a case which deals with a reply to a Facebook comment that included a link to a Wikipedia article about Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS).
The Oversight Board selected two new cases, appealed by Facebook users regarding two pieces of content related to Hay'at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), a group designated as a terrorist organization by the UN Security Council.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case which deals with an Instagram post featuring a drag performance and a caption that included the word 'faggy,' which Meta designates as a slur, being used in a reclaimed, positive, self-referential context.
Alleged Audio Call to Rig Elections in Iraqi Kurdistan
The Oversight Board selected a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding an audio clip posted by a prominent media outlet in Iraqi Kurdistan ahead of their parliamentary elections.
The Oversight Board selected three cases referred by Meta regarding content posted to Instagram, all involving symbols often used by hate groups but which can also have other uses.
The Oversight Board selected a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a video posted to Facebook which depicted an AI-manipulated version of a person who appears to be Brazilian soccer player Ronaldo Nazário encouraging others to download a popular online game called Plinco.
The Oversight Board selected a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding an image posted to Facebook that depicts a digitally altered headshot of the leader of a human rights organization in Peru.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle involving four images, three posted on Instagram and one on Facebook. The cases concern content featuring partially nude indigenous women.
Decision on Candidate for Mayor Assassinated in Mexico Bundle
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding four pieces of content concerning the assassination of José Alfredo Cabrera Barrientos, a mayoral candidate for a municipality in Mexico.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle appealed by Facebook users regarding content shared during the UK riots that took place between July 30 and August 7, 2024.
Decision on Footage of Terrorist Attack in Moscow Case Bundle
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding content containing a video that depicts the moment of a terrorist attack on visible victims at a concert venue in Moscow.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding an altered depiction of U.S. presidential candidate Kamala Harris and her running mate Tim Walz.
Criticism of EU Migration Policies and Immigrants Bundle
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle appealed by Facebook users regarding discussions centered around the European Union’s Pact on Migration and Asylum.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta regarding a video from Nigeria that shows two men who appear to have been beaten and detained for allegedly having sex with one another.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle regarding four pieces of content concerning the assassination of José Alfredo Cabrera Barrientos, a mayoral candidate for a municipality in Mexico.
Decision on Criminal Allegations Based on Nationality Case Bundle
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case bundle from Threads, Facebook, and Instagram regarding posts that make criminal allegations against groups on the basis of nationality, a protected characteristic.
Decision on Pakistan Political Candidate Accused of Blasphemy Case
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding an Instagram video containing accusations of blasphemy against a political candidate in Pakistan.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding cartoons that were posted in the context of college protests over the ongoing Israel-Gaza conflict.
Decision on Anti-Colectivos Content in Post-Election Venezuela Bundle
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a bundle of cases concerning two pieces of content posted to Facebook and Instagram regarding “Colectivos,” an umbrella term used to describe irregular armed gangs or paramilitary-style groups closely aligned with the government in Venezuela.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a bundle of cases concerning three pieces of content referencing the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas.
The Oversight Board selected a user-appealed case bundle regarding two pieces of content on Facebook and Instagram involving responses to transgender people playing competitive sports and using public bathrooms.
Anti-Colectivos Content in Post-Election Venezuela
The Oversight Board selected a Meta-referred expedited case bundle concerning two pieces of content posted to Facebook and Instagram regarding “Colectivos,” an umbrella term used to describe irregular armed gangs or paramilitary-style groups closely aligned with the government in Venezuela.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding an image of a drawing of Yesenia Zamudio with a quote about her quest for justice for the 2016 killing of her daughter.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a statement posted to Instagram that included the phrase: “Death to the Chinese Communist Party!”
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case bundle regarding two pieces of content posted to Facebook supporting the exclusion of Indigenous Australians from disputed lands using cursing and calling Indigenous Australians “ratbags.”
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by Facebook and Instagram users regarding two pieces of content containing artificial explicit images.
The Oversight Board selected a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a video from Nigeria that shows two men who appear to have been beaten and detained for allegedly having sex with one another.
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle appealed by Facebook users regarding content containing a video that depicts the moment of a terrorist attack on visible victims at a concert venue in Moscow.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case from Facebook regarding a post containing infographics that provide instructions for testicular self-examination.
Criminal Allegations Based on Nationality Case Bundle
The Oversight Board selected a case bundle from Threads, Facebook, and Instagram regarding posts that make criminal allegations against groups on the basis of nationality, a protected characteristic.
Decision on Politician's Comments on Demographic Changes
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a video of a French politician making claims about the colonization of Europe.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case from Facebook regarding a video containing a series of racist, anti-semitic, and homophobic meme images.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case from Instagram regarding images illustrating a fictional social media interaction intended to criticize Elon Musk.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on two cases from Facebook regarding a member of the Proud Boys convicted and sentenced for participating in the January 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol.
Decision on Weapons Post LInked to Sudan’s Conflict
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta regarding a Facebook post with instructions for making an explosive, followed by a statement of support for the Sudanese Armed Forces.
Australian Electoral Commission’s Voting Rules Bundle
The Oversight Board selected two cases concerning users’ commentary around a tweet from the Australian Electoral Commission that discusses voting multiple times at the polls.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a video of President Biden and his granddaughter that was altered in a way that removed the context and distorted his actions.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a photo containing a list of false facts about the Holocaust which, as a result, imply denial of the Holocaust.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on two cases, one from Facebook and another from Instagram, regarding content providing education about ovulation.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding an Instagram post of a woman with the accompanying caption “Alhamdulillah” which translates to “Praise be to God.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a video posted to Facebook of dark-skinned men driving in France that is accompanied by a dehumanizing caption.
The Oversight Board selects a case appealed by an Instagram user regarding a video of an unveiled Iranian woman being confronted by a male judicial officer.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on two cases appealed by a Facebook user regarding videos of an individual claiming to have experienced positive physical results from a fruit juice diet.
The Oversight Board selects a bundle of cases appealed by multiple users regarding two Facebook posts concerning political content within the context of Greek elections.
The Oversight Board selects a case referred by Meta regarding a Facebook post with instructions for making an explosive, followed by a statement of support for the Sudanese Armed Forces.
The Oversight Board selects a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a video of President Biden and his granddaughter that was altered in a way that removed the context and distorted his actions.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta regarding an Instagram video that captures a user’s call for women to join a political protest against the Cuban government.
The Oversight Board selects a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a post in Polish containing hateful rhetoric targeting the transgender community.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a TV reporter's response to an excerpt of a video interview in which Kanye West (Ye) makes antisemitic remarks.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a post in which a user uses humor to criticize a statement by Hezbollah secretary-general, Hassan Nasrallah.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a post in which a user recommends that a hotel owned by a prominent Ethiopian general be burned down immediately.
The Oversight Board selects a case appealed by an Instagram user regarding a post containing a cartoon character with accompanying text of false facts about the Holocaust.
Decision on Three Videos Critiquing a Turkish Government Official’s Response to the Turkey Earthquake
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by Facebook and Instagram users regarding videos criticizing a prominent member of the Republican People’s Party for their response to the earthquake centered in the Kahramanmaraş province.
Decision on a Post Describing an Experience with Ketamine as a Medical Treatment
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta regarding an Instagram post describing a user’s experience with ketamine for the medical treatment of anxiety and depression.
Video Featuring Communal Violence in the Indian state of Odisha
The Oversight Board selects a case referred by Meta regarding a video depicting a fight that broke out during a religious procession in the Indian state of Odisha.
Case Bundle Featuring Videos Making Claims About a Fruit Juice-Based Diet
The Oversight Board selects two cases appealed by a Facebook user regarding videos of an individual claiming to have experienced positive physical results from a fruit juice diet.
The Oversight Board selected a case referred by Meta regarding an Instagram post calling for the women of Cuba to rise up against the government and using dehumanizing language towards men.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision on Cambodian Prime Minister Video
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta concerning a video in which Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen threatens his political opponents.
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case which deals with content commemorating the death of Amilcar Cabral, 20th century anti-colonial leader of Bissau-Guinean and Cape Verdean heritage.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision on Brazilian General’s Speech Video
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appeal by a Facebook user concerning a video of a Brazilian general disputing Brazil’s election results.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision on Mistreatment of Armenian Prisoners of War Video
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta concerning a video posted to Facebook depicting the mistreatment of Armenian prisoners of war.
Videos Criticizing a Turkish Government Official’s Response to the Turkey Earthquake
Today, the Oversight Board selected a case bundle appealed by Facebook and Instagram users regarding three videos which all depict a member of Turkey’s Justice and Development Party criticizing a prominent member of the Republican People’s Party for their response to the February 6th earthquake.
Post Describing an Experience with Ketamine as a Medical Treatment
The Oversight Board selected a case referred by Meta regarding an Instagram post describing a user’s experience with ketamine for the medical treatment of anxiety and depression by medical professionals.
Oversight Board Selects a Case Regarding a Video Expressing Concerns About Men
Today, the Oversight Board selected a case appealed by an Instagram user regarding a video in Swedish containing a woman’s discussion about the experiences men and women have of one another as well as hatred between genders. The woman in the video acknowledges her generalized hatred of men and refers to herself as a “man hater” and then discusses the difference between women’s hatred of men and men’s hatred of women.
Today, the Oversight Board selected a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a post containing a photo depicting a woman with a black eye. The post was accompanied by a caption that mocked the woman’s condition.
Oversight Board Selects a PAO on Meta’s treatment of the word “Shaheed” when used to reference an individual designated under our Dangerous Individuals and Organizations (DOI) policy
The Oversight Board announced the selection of a Policy Advisory Opinion (PAO) referred by Meta regarding Meta’s treatment of the word “Shaheed” when used to reference an individual designated under our Dangerous Organizations and Individuals (DOI) policy
Oversight Board Selects a Case Regarding a Video of Parts of a Brazilian General’s Speech and Caption that Call Election Results Into Question and Promote a Siege of Federal Institutions
Oversight Board selects a case regarding a video of parts of a Brazilian General’s speech and caption that call election results into question and promote a siege of federal institutions
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Call for the Donation of Pharmaceutical Drugs in Sri Lanka
The Oversight Board makes a decision on case referred by Meta concerning a Facebook post of a Medical Organization in Sri Lanka requesting pharmaceutical drug donations.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Involving a Cartoon Depicting Iran’s Supreme Leader
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by a Facebook user involving a cartoon shared on a public group of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Photo of an Individual Killed in Ukraine During the Russian Invasion
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a photo of an individual killed in Ukraine during the Russian invasion with text containing an excerpt from a World War II era poem.
Oversight Board Selects Case Involving a Cartoon Depicting Iran’s Supreme Leader
Oversight Board selects a case appealed by a Facebook user involving a cartoon shared on a public group of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Post Calling for Violence in Ethiopia
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta regarding a post by the Tigray Communications Affairs Bureau Facebook page calling for violence in Ethiopia.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Comment with a Cartoon Depicting Violence by the Police in Colombia
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a comment with a cartoon depicting violence by the police in Colombia.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Post from a News Outlet Discussing the Taliban Government in Afghanistan
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a post discussing the new government in Afghanistan under the Taliban.
Oversight Board Selects a Case Regarding A Photo of an Individual Killed in Ukraine During the Russian Invasion with Text Containing an Excerpt from a World War II Era Poem
Oversight Board selects a case appealed by a Facebook user regarding a post containing an image of an individual killed in Ukraine during the Russian invasion with text containing an excerpt from a World War II era poem.
Oversight Board Selects Case Regarding A Veiled Threat of Violence Based on Lyrics from a Drill Rap Song
Oversight Board selects a case referred by Meta regarding an Instagram post that contained a video and text caption referencing the lyrics from a Drill Rap Song.
Oversight Board Selects a PAO on the Removal of COVID-19 Misinformation
The Oversight Board announced the selection of a policy advisory opinion (PAO) referred by Meta regarding how we handle health misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Post Containing Pictures of Derogatory Words in Arabic
Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by an Instagram user concerning a carousel post with each picture depicting a different word in Arabic that can be used in a derogatory way towards men.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision Regarding a Graphic Video Depicting a Civilian Victim of Violence in Sudan
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case referred by Meta regarding a graphic video posted on a user’s Facebook profile page which shows a victim of violence following a military coup in Sudan.
Meta withdraws a Policy Advisory Opinion Request Related to Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine
Meta withdraws a policy advisory opinion (PAO) request related to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine that had previously been referred to the Oversight Board.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision on a Case Depicting Indigenous Artwork and Discussing Residential Schools
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a picture of a traditional wampum belt depicting indigenous artwork and discussing residential schools.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision on a Case Regarding a Post Discussing a Substance with Psychoactive Properties
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case appealed by an Instagram user regarding a picture posted discussing a substance with psychoactive properties.
Oversight Board Selects a PAO on Facebook’s Cross-Check Policies
The Oversight Board selects a case referred by Facebook that is a policy advisory opinion regarding how we can continue to improve our cross-check system.
Oversight Board Makes a Decision on a case related to an Al Jazeera post on tensions between Israel and Palestine
The Oversight Board makes a decision on a case regarding a post taken down on Facebook for violating our policy on dangerous individuals and organizations
Facebook Response to Oversight Board on post regarding Abdullah Ӧcalan
Facebook's response to the Oversight Board's decision and recommendations on a post regarding Abdullah Ӧcalan, a founder of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK).
Oversight Board Selects a PAO on Sharing Private Residential Information
The Oversight Board selects a Policy Advisory Opinion on sharing private residential information and when that information should be considered private.